The Madhya Pradesh government school education department is under scrutiny after a state-wide probe into alleged financial irregularities involving government payments of Rs 648 crore identified the highest number of offices involved in the scandal.

According to the findings, 45 out of 187 Drawing and Disbursing Offices (DDOs) flagged across different government departments belong to school education – the highest from any department. Revenue follows with 43 and tribal affairs with 26 such offices. The state law enforcement personnel accounts for 12 flagged DDOs, forest nine and health eight.

For related coverage, explore our detailed analysis on Technology and Digital Systems.

Financial Irregularities and Suspicious Transactions

The probe has separately identified around Rs 305 crore in 199 suspicious transactions involving transfers to private bank accounts linked to authorities and employees, including accounts of wives and relatives. Another Rs 293 crore that was supposed to remain in Treasury Personal Deposit (PD) accounts was transferred to other bank accounts.

The SFIC was constituted on May 9, 2023, under the Directorate of Treasuries and Accounts to analyse data generated through the government's treasury software and identify suspicious or potentially fraudulent payments. The inquiry has found vulnerabilities across several links in the system.

In one set of cases, duplicate employee codes meant the same employee could potentially appear as two separate records in the system, creating a route for duplicate payments. In others, DDO login passwords were shared with employees, potentially allowing transactions to be carried out using an authorised officer's credentials.

Investigation Process and Vulnerabilities

The inquiry has resulted in recovery and reversal of a substantial amount, though a significant balance remains to be accounted for. The government official said, 'FIRs have been registered against at least over 50 officials over the past three years before the relevant agencies.' The government has since introduced additional safeguards to prevent such irregularities.

The investigation highlights the need for stricter oversight and monitoring of financial transactions in government departments. The SFIC's findings demonstrate the importance of data analysis and system validation in preventing financial irregularities.

Madhya Pradesh’s School Education Department, already facing scrutiny over the functioning and quality of government schools, has emerged as the department with the highest number of offices that were flagged in a state-wide probe into alleged financial irregularities involving government payments to the tune of Rs 648 crore. The findings are part of an inquiry SFIC has identified Rs 349 crore in irregular transfers and another Rs 299 crore in suspicious, irregular, fraudulent, duplicate or excess payments, all of which together amount to Rs 648 crore under scrutiny from 2023 till the present date.

A senior official from the state’s Accounts and Treasury Department, however, explained, "The Rs 600 crore figure which has come to the fore is data collected from across the districts in bits and pieces and sent to the collectorate level. We have not officially communicated this figure to the finance department.

Read More: 2 Chinese: survivors from vessel that sank off Odisha coast questioned by joint team

These cases come under inquiry after the system throws up an alert over a discrepancy in payments. It's investigated, and only then can we say whether the amount was siphoned off or was a genuine transaction." Of the 187 Drawing and Disbursing Offices (DDOs) flagged across different government departments, 45 belong to school education — the highest from any department.

Revenue follows with 43 and tribal affairs with 26 such offices. The state law enforcement personnel accounts for 12 flagged DDOs, forest nine and health eight. Higher education and public works departments have five each, records show.

'Money transferred into accounts of spouses' The probe has separately identified around Rs 305 crore in 199 suspicious transactions involving transfers to private bank accounts linked to authorities and employees, including accounts of wives and relatives in several cases. Another Rs 293 crore that was supposed to remain in Treasury Personal Deposit (PD) accounts was transferred to other bank accounts, according to the inquiry details.

Together, these two categories account for nearly Rs 600 crore. The SFIC was constituted on May 9, 2023, under the Directorate of Treasuries and Accounts, to analyse data generated through the government's treasury software and identify suspicious or potentially fraudulent payments.

Unlike a conventional inquiry that begins with a complaint against an individual, the SFIC starts with the payment data itself, looking for transactions and patterns that deviate from the normal government payment process. At the centre of this process is the Integrated Financial Management Information System (IFMIS), through which government payments are processed.

Employee payments depend on several linked pieces of information, including the employee's identity and code, salary entitlement, filed mobile number and bank-account details. The SFIC's inquiry has found vulnerabilities across these links.

'A route for duplicate payments' In one set of cases, duplicate employee codes meant the same employee could potentially appear as two separate records in the system, creating a route for duplicate payments. In others, DDO login passwords were shared with employees, potentially allowing transactions to be carried out using an authorised officer's credentials.

The inquiry also found instances where filed mobile numbers were changed, potentially diverting OTPs, and cases where employee records were not adequately matched with the names attached to bank accounts, records show. The inquiry has resulted in recovery and reversal of a substantial amount, though a significant balance remains to be accounted for.

The SFIC documents record Rs 56 crore recovered and Rs 164 crore in irregular transfers reversed, together amounting to around Rs 220 crore. Where the examination points to criminal wrongdoing, cases can move into criminal inquiry.

A government official stated, “FIRs have been filed against at least over 50 authorities over the past three years before the relevant agencies.” The official stated, “The government has since introduced additional safeguards, including system validation to prevent duplicate employee codes, restrictions on DDOs changing employees' filed mobile numbers, system-based limits on salary and allowance payments, matching salary payments with an employee's grade and prescribed salary, and mandatory two-factor authentication for system logins.”