DATE: THURSDAY, AUGUST 27, 2026
★ SPECIAL PRINT EDITION ★
SECTION: ENTERTAINMENT

Yash's Toxic: A Fairy Tale for Grown-Ups Sparks Debate Over Creative Process

Yash's Toxic: A Fairy Tale for Grown-Ups Sparks Debate Over Creative Process

Aug 27, 2026 - 15:11
0
‘I write something, shoot something else’: Internet digs up old video of Geetu Mohandas talking about Yash's Toxic
Listen to Story ~2m
Translate Article
0:00 Ready 0:00
Key Highlights:
  • The latest controversy surrounding Yash's 'Toxic' has sparked a heated debate about the role of the screenwriter in a film's creative p
  • According to Geetu, her writing process is 'crazy, erratic' and not something she can plan out like a traditional script. She explained
  • However, not everyone was pleased with Geetu's approach. Some took to social media to criticise her for not following a traditional scr

The latest controversy surrounding Yash's 'Toxic' has sparked a heated debate about the role of the screenwriter in a film's creative process. Geetu Mohandas, who received co-credit for story, screenplay, and dialogues in the film, shared her thoughts on the matter in a recent interview.

According to Geetu, her writing process is 'crazy, erratic' and not something she can plan out like a traditional script. She explained that her team often improvises on set and that she doesn't stick to the script. 'It’s not something I know like, okay, this is the beginning, this is the middle, this is the end,' she stated.

For related coverage, explore our detailed analysis on Technology and Digital Systems.

Geetu's Creative Process

However, not everyone was pleased with Geetu's approach. Some took to social media to criticise her for not following a traditional screenwriting process. 'KVN Productions should have listened to this disclaimer,' wrote one user, referring to the producer.

The internet had a field day when Geetu's statement resurfaced, with many users sharing their opinions on social media. Some defended her approach, pointing out that numerous directors also don't fully stick to the script and still execute successful work. 'So many directors also dont fully stick to the script, they still execute work,' wrote one user.

Despite the controversy surrounding its creative process, Yash's 'Toxic' performed well at the box office. The film collected over ₹100 crore domestically and ₹140 crore worldwide on its opening day.

Internet Reacts

With its strong performances from the cast, including Yash, Kiara Advani, Nayanthara, Huma Qureshi, Tara Sutaria, and Rukmini Vasanth, 'Toxic' was expected to do well. The film's success is a testament to the talent of its cast and crew.

In conclusion, Geetu Mohandas' statement about her creative process in 'Toxic' has sparked a debate about the role of the screenwriter in a film's production. While some defend her approach, others criticise it for not following traditional screenwriting methods. Regardless, the film's success is a testament to its talented cast and crew.

Toxic: A Fairy Tale for Grown-Ups was released in theatres on Wednesday amid high expectations from Yash’s fans. However, the Geetu Mohandas film, in which the actor received co-credit for story, screenplay and dialogues, failed to impress many.

The internet even dug up a 2021 interview of Geetu talking about the film, chalking down the criticism for it to her writing process. ( It can get crazy when you have more than one person collaborating with you on a script. Because they can just throw stones and walk away.

Read More: 8 Greatest: Historical Epics of All Time, Ranked (#1 Is a True Masterpiece)

My process is quite crazy, erratic, and I arrive at it later. It’s not something I know like, okay, this is the beginning, this is the middle, this is the end.

It doesn’t work like that for me.” She also stated that she and her team tend to improvise on set.She also spoke about Toxic, which she described as a ‘gangster drama with a female gaze’ and stated, “All the scripts I’ve written are It’s the first time for my next film, I have a writer’s room, and I think they’ve given up on me. They hate me.

You have to evolve; I get bored otherwise. So, I think I write something, I shoot something else, I edit something else, and then the film is out. Then I’m happy.

I never stick to the script. For my next film, I’m meeting producers. It’s the one thing I keep telling them.

You’re not gonna get what you’re reading.”Internet reacts to Geetu’s statement The internet, already reacting to Toxic with trolls and memes, had a field day when Geetu’s statement resurfaced. “KVN Productions should have listened to this disclaimer,” wrote one X (formerly Twitter) user, referring to the producer.

Konanki Venkata Narayana and Yash produced it through KVN Productions and Monster Mind Creations LLP, respectively. One called it, “Toxic: The Torture. Director's cut.

70mm Imax.” “Maybe this explains why #Toxic ended up receiving such mixed reactions. That creative freedom clearly comes with its own risks — and #Toxic seems to be one such example,” wrote one X user while another added, “That's why it's an outdated stuff in the movie because you don't have clarity or vision for your project.

Your lack of vision is clear on the screen. And you are flaunting it? Wow!”However, there were those who defended Geetu, pointing out that numerous directors tend to work in a similar fashion.

“So many directors also dont fully stick to the script, they still execute work. Somehow she is looked at in a diff lens,” defended one X user, while another wrote, “She is right.

What ever you write on paper it does not com on screen exactly like that, only a person who works a film set will relate to this.”Toxic stars Yash, Kiara Advani, Nayanthara, Huma Qureshi, Tara Sutaria and Rukmini Vasanth. The film collected over ₹100 crore domestically and ₹140 crore worldwide on its opening day.

Frequently Asked Questions

Geetu Mohandas has stated that her writing process is 'crazy, erratic' and not something she can plan out like a traditional script.

The internet reacted with both praise and criticism towards Geetu's approach, with some defending her while others criticise it for not following traditional screenwriting methods.

What's Your Reaction?

Like Like 0
Dislike Dislike 0
Love Love 0
Funny Funny 0
Wow Wow 1
Sad Sad 0
Angry Angry 1

Movies, series, and everything happening around Indian entertainment keep me busy. I cover OTT releases, box-office conversations, celebrity news, and the changing world of streaming, with a particular interest in the stories and trends that audiences are talking about right now.

Comments (0)

User