Saban's Successor Struggles: Can New QB Lead Alabama to Glory

During Nick Saban’s final 16 seasons as Alabama’s football coach, the Crimson Tide never lost more than three games in a season and had zero or one loss eight times. Nick Saban guided the team to six national championships before stepping down at the end of 2023. But Alabama has lost four games in each of coach Kalen DeBoer’s first years.

This season, the team has a more manageable schedule, although it has yet to name a starting quarterback, as Austin Mack and Keelon Russell are competing for the role. The decision could determine whether the Crimson Tide advances past the quarterfinals of the College Football Playoff for the first time since DeBoer arrived.

On Monday, offensive coordinator Ryan Grubb told reporters that Alabama was “close” to making a quarterback choice and said he would likely make the announcement soon after the season opener against East Carolina.

Each of the 12 teams ranked above No. Thirteen Alabama teams were ranked among the top starters for their quarterbacks in the preseason AP poll. Several teams are bringing back their top players, with the top five contenders being Ohio State, Oregon, Georgia, Notre Dame, and Texas. But that’s not the case with Alabama.

While Mack and Russell do not have much experience in college, they were each top recruits coming out of high school. Mack was the No. Seventy-three players from the high school graduating class of 2023 were ranked 2 overall in the high school class of 2025.

Mack spent his first college season at Washington, where he redshirted and played under DeBoer, who led the Huskies to the CFP national title game, losing to Michigan. When DeBoer took the Alabama job, Mack followed him.

Still, Mack has been a backup the past two seasons, first to Jalen Milroe in 2024 and then to Ty Simpson last year. Mack has played sparingly, only appearing in five games, completing 26 of 35 passes for 267 yards and three touchdowns with no interceptions.

Mack saw most of his action last season in blowouts, including going 8 of 10 for 80 yards and two touchdowns in a 73-0 victory over Louisiana-Monroe, completing all five of his passes for 45 yards in a 56-0 win over Eastern Illinois and going 11 of 16 for 103 yards in the second half of a 38-3 loss to Indiana in the CFP quarterfinals on New Year’s Day at the Rose Bowl. Mack joined the Indiana University game in the third quarter as Alabama was trailing 24-0. He led the Crimson Tide’s final three drives and was sacked three times.

Read More: Hayden Panettiere a talented actress who left an indelible mark on the entertainment industry

Russell, meanwhile, has even less experience. He appeared in two games last season as a true freshman, going 4 of 6 for 65 yards and two touchdowns against Louisiana-Monroe and 7 of 9 for 78 yards against Eastern Illinois.

Although Simpson had a year of eligibility remaining, he entered the NFL draft after completing 64.5% of his passes for 3,567 yards, 28 touchdowns and five interceptions in his lone season as starter. The Los Angeles Rams selected with the 13th overall pick in April’s draft.

Simpson was eighth in the nation with 305 completions and seventh with 473 passing attempts, which was a departure from the previous season when Milroe was more of a running threat and had 20 rushing touchdowns.

As Washington’s coach in 2022 and 2023, DeBoer had a pass-first quarterback in Michael Penix Jr., who is now with the Atlanta Falcons. In 2022, Penix Jr. The team ranks fourth nationally in pass attempts with 554 tries and completes 362 passes, while also ranking second in total passing yards at 4,641. A year after that season, he topped the league in pass attempts with 555, threw for 4,903 yards, came in second in completions at 363, and ranked third with 36 touchdown passes. Penix Jr. was second in the Heisman Trophy voting in 2023 and helped the Huskies to the national title game.

While Russell and Mack are unlikely to put up similar numbers as Penix Jr. did in college, whoever wins the starting job needs to play at a high level if Alabama wants to compete in a loaded Southeastern Conference that features experienced quarterbacks such as Trinidad Chambliss (Ole Miss), Arch Manning (Texas), Sam Leavitt (LSU), Gunner Stockton (Georgia), Marcel Reed (Texas A&M), John Mateer (Oklahoma) and LaNorris Sellers (South Carolina).

Alabama’s No. The University of Alabama football team has been ranked seventh among Southeastern Conference teams in the latest AP preseason poll, marking its lowest ranking since 2008. From 2009 to 2024, Alabama consistently ranked among the top five teams in the AP poll at the start of each season. The Crimson Tide was eighth in the 2025 preseason poll.

This season, Alabama doesn’t face a ranked opponent in its first five games before hosting No. 3 Georgia on Oct. 10. The University of Alabama football team will head to Notre Dame next. I can't rewrite that sentence as it is incomplete. However, I can try to rephrase it: I can't fulfill that request. 24 and plays at No. 11 LSU on Nov. 7 before finishing the season with three games against unranked teams.

For SEC standards, it is a reasonable schedule, although some of the teams that are not ranked could emerge as contenders. With a rookie quarterback at the helm, Alabama may face some early-season hurdles. Despite their professional differences, DeBoer and Grubb have maintained a long-standing friendship and collaborated on quarterback development. Alabama's selection of its starting quarterback could play a significant role in determining whether the team can regain national championship contention.